P71028For my exquisite 1979 Electra, planned obsolescence did not work out so well. It was probably a grand Buick for that time, and one of the last with tail fins! It was elegant. It was big. It was steel. It was made to last ten years or 100,000 miles . . . and that was it. Seriously, as much as I enjoyed that car, it did not want go to much farther than it was designed to go. It limped along for almost 20,000 miles more, but was not happy about it, and was really tired and worn out by the time it went to Buick Heaven.

Planned obsolescence used to mean something completely different in landscaping. Yes, we all know what it means now; that many of the so called ‘sustainable’ modern cultivars last only a few years so that they need to be replaced sooner than older cultivars. What it used to mean is that fast growing plants were used to get a landscape established quickly, while more desirable but slower plants took their time growing. As the more desirable plants matured, the fast growing plants could be removed.

For example, a large condominium complex was landscaped primarily with Norway maples and flowering pears. These trees would eventually grow to be proportionate to the buildings and the spaces that they shade. To provide shade sooner, and to help the landscape look established by the second summer, common cottonwoods were incorporated into larger areas. Their placement was not as important as it was to the maples and pears, but was strategic enough to avoid the other trees and buildings as long as possible. The intention was to allow the cottonwoods to be the prominent trees in the landscape only temporarily, but to remove them as the maples and pears matured. It was a practical technique used by landscape designers for as long as anyone can remember.

Sadly, few modern ‘gardeners’ understand this concept. The cottonwoods did not get removed when they should have been. They overwhelmed and crowded the other trees, and caused them to be disfigured as they grew. The cottonwood roots broke pavement and ruined lawns. Then, after all the damage and destruction, . . . the cottonwoods died, like cottonwoods do. Now the landscape is shaded by healthy but distorted maples and pears. The plan did not work very well.

Now, such planned obsolescence is simply impractical for trees. Even if those maintaining landscapes were reliable enough to follow through with such plans, modern tree preservation ordinances would prevent them from getting permits to remove temporary trees. Planned obsolescence can work with smaller shrubbery and perennials in home gardens, but those of us who use the technique must follow through with our plans so that things do not get too crowded.

10 thoughts on “Planned Obsolescence

    1. Oh! That is something that my clients remind me all the time. It makes me so angry when they tell me that they will be moving in a few years, so they do not care what damage their fast growing big trees cause. They just want it to get as big as possible as fast as possible to add resale value to their home. They have no loyalty to the community because they are just here to make a buck and then move on, leaving problems for someone else. Oh my! Enough of my rant.


      1. Well, that is another topic; but yes, to be brief, my ancestors have been here for generations, longer than anyone else, but I can not even afford to live in my hometown because of all the people who have moved here and ruined our culture and idyllic lifestyle, but do not even care about the community.


      2. I think it is happening every where. This area was once all just beach cottages, small houses with lawn all round, but this is now a very “desirable” area. Now huge houses surrounded by a small concrete bbq area. Fortunately we bought in before the rot set in.

        Liked by 1 person

  1. We have a problem in this country with people planting leylandii hedges and then letting them get overgrown, blocking out light. Also eucalyptus trees which grow enormous quite quickly. Often people intend to keep them trimmed, but if they move house the incoming residents don’t always keep up the maintenance.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh yes, I am familiar with that one as well. Leyland cypress are a problem here, because by the time the get big enough to function as windbreaks as they were intended to do, they die suddenly. It would not be so bad if they got planted with pines to replace them as they die out, but that technique is not longer used. We do not use Leyland cypress in refined landscapes much anymore, but I hear that the cultivars are still popular elsewhere.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Tony,
    First, don’t be sorry about “recycling ” your articles. They are new to many of us.

    Next, great car! I had a 1978 Chevy Monte Carlo that I finally traded at 130,000. I got a Honda. It didn’t last nearly so long (despite the Honda hype). Never again.

    And I loved reading all the comments on this piece. This same sort of thing is going on right now both where I grew up and where I live. It’s just crazy to watch.


    Liked by 1 person

    1. Right now, I can not afford to be sorry about recycling. I really should not be writing as much as I do anyway.
      Heck! I do not even have time to go find a car! It is a long story, but to be brief, because I do not want to spend money on a vehicle that I can not enjoy like the old vehicles, I am driving one of the old farm pickups, which is as old as I am.
      You may have heard about new gasoline cars (very unlikely) being unavailable for sale in California fifteen years from now. It is silly; but at this point, I am not sure I care, not only because I am so unimpressed by contemporary cars, but because it would be so consistent with all this other craziness here.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s