Excessive soil amendment may be unnecessary.

Planting should not be complicated. The primary objective is to settle formerly contained roots into the ground safely. It includes motivating roots to disperse into surrounding soil. This might involve disruption of constricting or congested roots. It may involve addition of fertilizer. Soil amendment such as compost is likely useful to entice root growth outward.

For almost all substantial woody plants and most large perennials, this is only temporary. Their roots disperse faster than their original soil amendment decomposes. They require no more soil amendment incorporated into their soil afterward. Such incorporation would damage their dispersing roots. This could defeat the original purpose of soil amendment.

For such substantial plants, soil amendment only provides a transition into endemic soil. Without it, roots may be tempted to continue to grow within their original potting medium. If endemic soil is less appealing to them, they might lack motivation to disperse outward. Soil amendment mixed with their endemic soil provides them the motivation they require.

Mulching with soil amendment over the surface of the soil is a different procedure. Since it requires no incorporation into the soil, it severs no roots below the surface. Yet, it helps retain moisture and insulates the soil. As it decomposes, mulch adds organic nutrients to the soil. For established plants, mulching is a noninvasive technique with a few benefits.

Vegetable plants and annuals enjoy soil amendment more than more substantial plants. Proportionately, they consume much more of the nutrients that the amendments provide. Yet, they do not inhabit their soil long enough to crave more than they start with. Addition of amendment during their replacement damages no roots. It provides for the next phase.

Soil amendment is available either bagged or in bulk from nurseries and garden centers. Home garden generated compost is less expensive, since it costs nothing but effort. The process of composting is involved, but it utilizes otherwise useless garden detritus. Many home gardens generate more compost than they may use. Neighbors sometimes share.

5 thoughts on “Soil Amendment Might Be Overkill

    1. Thank you. I was hesitant to write about it because those who use soil amendments excessively insist that it is necessary. In the Santa Clara Valley, I know that it is not.

      Like

  1. Thank you for sharing such detailed and helpful information! It’s really useful to understand how soil amendment works differently for various types of plants and the importance of not overdoing it. I also love the reminder about the benefits of mulching and homemade compost — such simple yet effective ways to support healthy gardens.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. True, I can see how too much would be wasteful. In my case, I’m just starting out with heavy clay soil and creating a no-dig garden, so I’m layering compost and organic matter on top to improve the texture and drainage over time. Hopefully, as the layers break down, the soil will need much less amendment.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Beth@PlantPostings.com Cancel reply